From film scores and game sound effects to background music for short videos, AI music generation technology has permeated every corner of creative production. It is no longer a concept confined to science fiction films but a tangible productivity tool within reach. Users need only input a text description and select an emotional style to receive a structurally complete, high-quality musical piece within minutes. This transformation not only frees creators’ hands but, more importantly, liberates their imagination once technical barriers are swept away, the flow of inspiration becomes freer than ever before.
This evaluation will focus on five representative and distinctive AI music generation tools currently available on the market: AIVA, Soundraw, Boomy, Aimusic, and MakeBestMusic. We will conduct an in-depth analysis across multiple dimensions, including core functionality, operational logic, output quality, and applicable scenarios, to provide you with a detailed and objective reference guide. This will help you find the “digital instrument” that best suits your needs amidst this technological wave.
Among the numerous song mashup makers, each tool offers unique technical features. Among them, Text to Music stands as the most mainstream technological approach, with each implementation offering distinct advantages. Meanwhile, traditional AI song makers continue to evolve, providing users with increasingly rich creative experiences.
Evaluation Criteria
To ensure the fairness and professionalism of the evaluation, we have established the following assessment criteria:
- Ease of operation
- Scope of Style and Genre Coverage
- Professional-grade sound quality
- The degree of restriction on creative freedom
- Generation Speed and Stability
Each tool will undergo rigorous testing under identical conditions, including multiple rounds of generation with the same prompt, experimentation with different stylistic approaches, and professional analysis of output audio quality.
Functional Evaluation of Tool Generation Capabilities
- MakeBestMusic
- Feature Overview
Text to Music, known as Create Music within MakeBestMusic, as the platform’s core creative gateway, transforms the complex process of music composition into simple, intuitive text-based dialogue. Powered by an advanced deep learning architecture, this feature accurately parses users’ natural language descriptions and converts them into structurally complete professional musical compositions.
In practical applications, users can input expressive musical descriptions. For example: “Compose ambient music for a modern art exhibition opening, requiring ethereal and distant electronic tones with a slow, fluid rhythm to create an immersive sensory experience.” The system intelligently interprets the sonic qualities of “ethereal and distant,” the specific expression of “fluid rhythm,” and the emotional atmosphere required for an art exhibition.
This feature fully supports multilingual input systems and accurately comprehends professional musical terminology. Users can precisely specify desired beat patterns, tonal characteristics, and complex formal structures. The platform handles nuanced emotional expressions and unique stylistic features, accurately capturing users’ creative intentions and artistic aspirations.
- Operational Process Design
MakeBestMusic’s Text to Music feature employs an intuitive three-step process. Users first input a music description, including style, mood, and instrument requirements; then select structural parameters; and finally click generate to obtain a complete musical composition. The entire workflow is thoughtfully designed, allowing even beginners to get started quickly.
- Style and Genre Support
- Supports over 100 music genres, from classical to electronic music and everything in between.
- Able to understand complex style blending requests, such as “electronic dance music with jazz chords.”
- Possesses a strong ability to recognize ethnic music and regional styles
- Sound Quality and Generation Effects
- The output audio quality meets the CD standard of 44.1kHz/16-bit.
- The instrument tones are authentic and natural, especially in the reproduction of piano and string instruments.
- The musical structure is complete, with well-defined sections including an introduction, verses, and choruses.
- Generation Efficiency
- Generate a complete song in just 30 seconds.
- Supports batch generation of multiple versions
- Provide real-time progress updates during the generation process
- AIVA
- Operational Process Design
AIVA’s composition feature employs a professionally oriented three-step workflow. Users first select a preset style template or upload reference audio; next, they fine-tune parameters like tension and joyfulness using an emotion slider; finally, they confirm the output duration and structural complexity to generate professional-grade film scores. This process balances efficiency with expertise, making it ideal for users with clear creative objectives.
- Style and Genre Support
- Deeply supports over 20 film and television music styles, covering specific scenarios such as epic, suspense, romance, and science fiction.
- Specializes in recreating the styles of classical composers, such as “Hans Zimmer-esque grand symphonies” or “Joe Hisaishi-style soothing piano.”
- Demonstrates exceptional skill in blending Eastern and Western traditional instruments, capable of creating contemporary soundtracks featuring distinctive elements such as the shakuhachi and sitar.
- Sound Quality and Generation Effects
- Supports 48kHz/24-bit mastering-grade audio output with a dynamic range of up to 90dB
- The symphony’s orchestration is exceptionally faithful to the original, featuring rich string textures and powerful brass sections with remarkable projection.
- The work possesses a complete cinematic score structure, encompassing theme exposition, emotional progression, climactic release, and concluding resolution.
- Generation Efficiency
- Standard 3-minute music composition takes 3-4 minutes to generate; complex arrangement requests may require additional time.
- Supports generating multiple emotional variations from the same seed
- Display spectrum analysis and progress percentage during generation, enabling professional users to monitor generation quality in real time.
- Soundraw
- Operational Process Design
Soundraw employs a spiral workflow of “Generate-Edit-Customize.” Users first quickly obtain foundational melodies through intelligent recommendations; then freely adjust chord progressions and instrument combinations within the visual editor; finally, optimize details using AI enhancement features. This design strikes a balance between rapid initiation and deep control.
- Style and Genre Support
- Focusing on the pop music scene, covering over 30 modern electronic genres, including Future Bass, Tropical House, and more.
- Supports fusion of multiple styles, such as “electronic dance music blending City Pop with funk bass.”
- Optimized for short video scenarios, offering a 15-second highlight clip in rapid generation mode.
- Sound Quality and Generation Effects
- Output standard: 44.1kHz/16-bit, specifically optimized for streaming platforms
- The electronic sound library is rich and avant-garde, with synthesizer pads and lead tones standing out for their distinct texture.
- The structural design adheres to pop music standards and supports customizable verse-chorus length ratios.
- Generation Efficiency
- The basic version takes just one minute to generate, while a complete arrangement takes about two minutes.
- Supports simultaneous generation of up to 5 alternative options
- Real-time display of instrument track construction process, with support for pausing midway to adjust parameters
- Boomy
- Operational Process Design
Boomy embraces minimalism to deliver one-click creation. Users select foundational style tags, and the system instantly generates a complete song, refining the result through intelligent feedback mechanisms. This zero-barrier design truly achieves “click-to-create.”
- Style and Genre Support
- Focusing on 7 mainstream genres, including Lo-fi, Hip Hop, Electronic, and more
- Specializes in creating 15-60 second bite-sized music content tailored for short-form video platforms.
- Support fine-tuning styles using simple descriptive terms, such as “more melancholic” or “more lively.”
- Sound Quality and Generation Effects
- Outputs in 128kbps MP3 format, optimized for mobile playback.
- The rhythmic design is precise, and the drum arrangement aligns with contemporary pop aesthetics.
- The song features a simple and clear structure, focusing on crafting core memorable moments.
- Generation Efficiency
- Standard 3-minute soundtrack generation takes 2-3 minutes.
- Single generation provides 3 optional versions.
- A progress bar with stylized visual indicators provides an intuitive display of the generation stage.
- AImusic
- Operational Process Design
AImusic employs a classic text-driven composition workflow. Users describe musical scenarios in the input box or paste lyrics directly, select their desired style, and generate music instantly. Its no-registration requirement makes it the most convenient instant creation tool.
- Style and Genre Support
- Supports over 50 common music genres based on the Suno model
- Accurate understanding of multicultural scene descriptions, such as “Mediterranean-inspired light music” or “Nordic-inspired electronic music.”
- Supports multilingual lyrics adaptation, including English, Spanish, French, and other mainstream languages for melody generation.
- Sound Quality and Generation Effects
- Output quality: 44.1kHz/16-bit WAV format
- Natural texture for acoustic instruments like piano and guitar; clear synthesis for vocals
- Generated pieces feature a complete paragraph structure with adjustable intro/outro lengths.
- Generation Efficiency
- Standard generation time remains stable at approximately 2 minutes
- Supports continuous generation of different arrangement versions
- Concise progress prompts paired with estimated remaining time ensure a smooth experience
Comprehensive Scoring and Comparative Analysis
After thorough testing, the scores for each tool in music generation are as follows:
- MakeBestMusic：8.9/10
- AIVA：8.4/10
- Soundraw：8.7/10
- Boomy：8.3/10
- AImusic：8.5/10
Among numerous tools, MakeBestMusic leads in overall performance, particularly excelling in stylistic diversity and sound quality. Its Text to Music engine boasts the highest accuracy in text comprehension, effectively capturing the user’s creative intent.
How to Choose the Right AI Music Generation Tool
- Select based on creative requirements.
- All-Round Creative Needs: MakeBestMusic excels in stylistic diversity and functional completeness through its multi-model architecture and comprehensive creative ecosystem.
- Professional Film/TV Scoring & Classical Composition: AIVA stands out as the top choice for its nuanced emotional expression and MIDI export capabilities.
- Commercial Music Production & Deep Customization: Soundraw delivers comprehensive copyright protection and meticulous arrangement adjustments.
- Rapid Creation & Streaming Distribution: Boomy excels with lightning-fast generation and direct platform integration.
- Multi-Style Needs & Instant Creation: AImusic supports diverse genres and requires no registration.
- Select based on skill level.
- All Skill Levels: MakeBestMusic’s tiered feature design enables users to progress from beginner to expert entirely within the same platform.
- Beginner Users: Boomy and AImusic’s minimalist interfaces are ideal for those starting from scratch.
- Intermediate Users: Soundraw’s visual editor provides an excellent foundation for learning music composition.
- Professional Users: AIVA’s advanced parameter settings and MIDI editing capabilities meet the demands of professional production.
- Budget considerations
- Free Trial: AImusic is completely free, while Boomy and Soundraw offer free credits.
- Individual Creators: Soundraw’s monthly plan delivers the best value for money.
- Professional Teams: AIVA’s enterprise license includes full commercial usage rights.
- Flexible Options: MakeBestMusic provides multiple subscription plans ranging from free to professional, catering to different budget requirements.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: Can AI-generated music be used commercially?
Copyright policies vary significantly across platforms. Soundraw explicitly offers royalty-free commercial licenses, AIVA requires purchasing a commercial license, while Boomy permits monetization through streaming platform plays. MakeBestMusic provides clear commercial licensing options, enabling users to utilize generated content with confidence.
Q2：Is the length and quality of the generated songs guaranteed?
AIVA generates professional-grade music in 3-4 minutes; Soundraw balances quality and efficiency within 2 minutes. MakeBestMusic achieves professional-grade sound quality in under a minute, striking the optimal balance between speed and quality.
Q3：Can it mimic specific musical styles?
Each tool supports style learning, but their implementation methods differ. AIVA can generate music based on reference audio, Soundraw offers granular style parameter adjustments, while Boomy matches stylistic features through a tagging system. MakeBestMusic supports precise recognition of over 100 music genres and can understand complex style blending requirements.
Q4：How editable are the generated works?
AIVA supports MIDI export for in-depth editing within professional DAWs; Soundraw offers multi-track editing capabilities; Boomy and AImusic are primarily designed for direct use with finished tracks. MakeBestMusic provides a complete solution ranging from rapid generation to deep editing, catering to diverse editing needs across all skill levels.
Ushering in a New Era of Intelligent Music Creation
Among the five tools evaluated in this review, each demonstrates a distinct technical approach and application scenario. AIVA maintains the precise control expected of professional scoring tools. Soundraw represents a mature solution for commercial music production, Boomy redefines accessibility in mass music creation, and AImusic showcases the instant creation appeal of lightweight tools. At the same time， MakeBestMusic offers a unified solution for creators with diverse needs through its comprehensive creative capabilities and excellent cross-platform experience.
MakeBestMusic’s innovation lies in its ability to maintain the functional depth of professional tools while offering beginner-friendly usability. Its multi-model intelligent scheduling system automatically matches the optimal algorithm based on creative needs, ensuring users achieve an ideal creative experience across different scenarios. From capturing fleeting inspiration to producing professional-grade works, MakeBestMusic provides a complete creative loop.
AI music generation technology is currently undergoing rapid development, with functional boundaries between tools becoming increasingly blurred. Creators are advised to choose flexibly based on their actual needs: Boomy is ideal for quick creative validation, while AIVA enables professional-grade production. Opting for MakeBestMusic means gaining a continuously evolving creative partner that accompanies creators throughout their journey from beginner to expert.
With the deep integration of multimodal technologies, future AI music tools will inevitably become smarter and more user-friendly. Now is the perfect time to embrace this transformation—choose any tool to start creating, and carve out your own musical realm in this field brimming with possibilities.
